"The most error-strewn article, that on Dmitry Mendeleev, co-creator of the periodic table, illustrates this. Michael Gordin, a science historian at Princeton University who wrote a 2004 book on Mendeleev, identified 19 errors in Wikipedia and 8 in Britannica. These range from minor mistakes, such as describing Mendeleev as the 14th child in his family when he was the 13th, to more significant inaccuracies. Wikipedia, for example, incorrectly describes how Mendeleev's work relates to that of British chemist John Dalton. "Who wrote this stuff?" asked another reviewer. "Do they bother to check with experts?"
Из статьи Nature, 2005, сравнивающей качество научных статей в Википедии и Encyclopedia Britannica
This entry was originally posted at http://profpr.dreamwidth.org/444399.html. Please comment there using OpenID.
Другие новости от profpr.livejournal.com
Реклама на проекте
Труднее всего писать про Дмитрия Менделеева
Wednesday, 26 August, 19:08,
profpr.livejournal.com
Комментарии (0)